Home

Robin Hood Gardens

Poplar, London / 2014–16

Robin Hood Gardens was built for the Greater London Council to a design by Alison and Peter Smithson. It had 214 flats in two long concrete blocks in Poplar, with decks every third floor, around a landscaped mound. It was completed in 1972.

In March 2008 Tower Hamlets Council, which had taken it over from the GLC, decided to demolish it. A 2008 estimate put the repairs at £20m or more. The government granted immunity from listing in May 2009.

The west block came down from December 2017 and the east block in spring 2025. The site is now Blackwall Reach, with permission for up to 1,575 homes.

I photographed the estate in January 2014, and again in April and September 2016, when the west block had been emptied and the east block was still lived in.

A large shrub on a lawn in front of a long concrete block of flats with curtains in many windows and washing on some balconies.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016
Architect
Alison and Peter Smithson, for the Greater London Council
Built
Commissioned 1963 by the London County Council; new brief 1966 from the Greater London Council; on site 1968; completed 1972
Homes
214 flats in two blocks of seven and ten storeys
Listing
Listing refused 2008; certificate of immunity from listing 13 May 2009; in August 2015 the minister was minded to approve a second
Status
Demolished: west block December 2017 to spring 2018, east block December 2024 to spring 2025
Visits
January 2014; April and September 2016

Robin Hood Gardens was the Smithsons’ only council estate; its landlord decided to demolish it in March 2008, and the last of it came down seventeen years later.

The encounter

Interpretation, James Wakefield:

I first walked round Robin Hood Gardens in January 2014, a few months before I began photographing at Balfron Tower, a short walk away. I went back in April and September 2016, when the west block had been emptied and the east block was still lived in.

In September 2016 I showed photographs there with Transition Photographers, in a basement room the council lent us, as Robin Hood Gardens: Out of Time. Peter Luck and I wrote the history panels, which began: “Robin Hood Gardens has probably gathered to itself more mythology than any other social housing in Britain, certainly than any other in London.” We meant the show as a start on freeing its story “from the myths, positive or negative”.

Sunlit concrete block of flats framed by dark leaves, with a path and blue railings along its foot.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016
Wet road running under the railway viaduct towards a round tower, a dark tower block and three cranes, red buses on the right.
Blackwall, Poplar · January 2014

The promise, 1963–72

The London County Council gave the Smithsons their first commission in Poplar in 1963, for a site on Manisty Street. The Greater London Council, which replaced it in 1965, agreed to clear the nearby Grosvenor Buildings, and the site grew. A new brief came in 1966, building began in 1968, and the estate was finished in 1972.

Two long blocks, one of seven storeys and one of ten, follow the line of the roads on either side and shelter a garden between them. The decks were planned for the road side every third floor, with the living rooms. The bedrooms and dining-kitchens were planned to look over the garden.

The mound in the middle was made from the rubble of the buildings cleared for the estate. The Smithsons called the scheme “a demonstration of a more enjoyable way of living”.

Man in a light jacket stands behind blue railings in front of a block of flats.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016
Timber-edged steps and handrails between shrubs, with a tower block beyond.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016
Long concrete block of flats with many balconies behind a grassy lawn, shrubs under a cloudy sky.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016

The manual issued to those moving in stated: “The Greater London Council and its architects have been working on Robin Hood Gardens since 1963; its builders since 1968; it is now your turn to try and make it a place you will be proud to live in.”

Concrete access deck with frosted parapet panels, pipework and a pushchair, with tall buildings and sky beyond.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Access deck · September 2016

The deck itself is wide enough for the milkman to bring his cart along or for two women with prams to stop for a talk and still let the postman by.

Alison and Peter SmithsonThe Smithsons on Housing, BBC2, as quoted by Municipal Dreams, 1970

The reputation, 1972–2007

There was vandalism early on, though the reasons are not clear. In 1974 Alison Smithson wrote “The Violent Consumer”, trying to make sense of it.

Historic England advised against listing for the second time in August 2015. Its head of designation said the “streets-in-the-air” approach was “at least 20 years old” by 1972, and the architecture “bleak in many areas, particularly in communal spaces”.

Residents interviewed by Kois Miah and Nick Thoburn for Brutalism as Found spoke of the decks differently. “Here we all know each other,” William Fakamus said. Motiur Rahman remembered: “We always talked about the walkways being like Bangladesh.”

Concrete access deck with a door, two bicycles and a frosted-panel parapet under a cloudy sky.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Access deck · September 2016
Concrete access deck with a carpet draped over the parapet, and a city view beyond.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Access deck · September 2016

You know what they call this place around here? They call it Alcatraz. At least the people who don’t live in it do. My friends ask ‘How can you live there?’ but they can’t believe how nice it is inside.

A residentJohn Furse, The Smithsons at Robin Hood, PhD thesis, as quoted by Municipal Dreams, 1982
A large green shrub on patchy grass in front of a long concrete block of flats.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016

The decision, 2007–12

A survey in 2006 found defects in the outside walls, the roofs, the kitchens, the bathrooms and the wiring, according to Municipal Dreams.

The developer’s statement to the 2012 planning committee said it had been estimated in 2008 that putting this right would cost at least £20m. That was when the council adopted its plan for the area. The council’s own 2016 report gave about £21m.

Planning committee report, March 2012: immunity from listing granted in May 2009, and the applicant's view that 'at least £20 million would be required' to remedy the defects.
Strategic Development Committee report, London Borough of Tower Hamlets, PDF pp. 56–57 (two consecutive pages joined)15 March 2012London Borough of Tower Hamlets, democracy.towerhamlets.gov.ukWhat this provesThe date of the first certificate of immunity, and the repair estimate the developer cited in 2012. The £20m figure is the developer's statement, quoted in the council's report; the survey behind it is not shown.

Between August and November 2007 consultants for English Partnerships asked people living in the area, which had about 300 households. They made 110 home visits. Of the households with a preference, 81% chose knocking the estate down and rebuilding, and 17% keeping it.

The consultants warned that the figure “needs to be treated with some caution”. Support was tied to being able to stay in the area and keep a council tenancy, and they called the consensus “a relatively fragile one”. 77% said they wanted to remain in the neighbourhood.

Consultation report, para. 2.15: of those with a preference, 81% preferred demolition and replacement and 17% keeping the estate, a figure to be 'treated with some caution'.
Blackwall Reach Regeneration Project, Phase 1 Consultation Report, p. 11February 2008English Partnerships; published by the London Borough of Tower HamletsWhat this provesWhat residents who answered the 2007 home-visit survey said, and the consultants' own warning about the number. It does not separate Robin Hood Gardens households from the rest of the area.

On 5 March 2008 the council’s cabinet agreed to demolish numbers 1 to 214. Tenants were given decant status from September 2008, with the option of a new housing association home or another council home through the decant. A petition against demolition was handed in at the meeting.

In July 2008 the culture minister, Margaret Hodge, refused to list the estate. “Anyone who wants to list that place should try living there,” she said later. “It is simply not fit for purpose.”

The Department for Culture, Media and Sport granted a five-year certificate of immunity from listing on 13 May 2009.

On 15 March 2012 the council’s planning committee voted five to nil for outline permission for up to 1,575 homes. Two residents of the estate were among the five speakers, on opposite sides.

Darren Pauling, a resident and chair of the Millennium Green Trust, said a petition he had carried out a few years earlier found that 120 of 130 households wanted refurbishment. He had used interpreters. Mohammed Yousuf, chair of the tenants’ and residents’ association, said most of its members supported the regeneration; the minutes record that residents were “sick of housing problems on the estate”.

Planning committee report, p. 58: 1,575 homes after demolishing 252, with 566 for social rent, 132 intermediate and 877 for market sale.
Strategic Development Committee report, London Borough of Tower Hamlets, PDF p. 5815 March 2012London Borough of Tower Hamlets, democracy.towerhamlets.gov.ukWhat this provesWhat the applicant's plans promised for the whole regeneration site, as reported to the committee: a new home for every secure tenant, and 566 social-rent homes against 207 existing. Not what was later built, or who moved in.

The decant, 2008–24

Terracotta hoarding showing a woman drinking from a cup and the words "Blackwall Regenerated", in front of a mesh fence and a tall concrete block.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016
Palisade gate with warning signs beside an orange hoarding reading "Be Registered", with a block of flats and trees behind.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016

I like the views from the windows, I like the light. It is close to the shops and the DLR station. The flat is good, it just needs fixing up

Harun Miah, tenantDelwar Hussain, “Return to Robin Hood Gardens”, Spitalfields Life, 20 August 2016

Miah told Delwar Hussain in August 2016 that his family had lived in the flat for just under a year, and that its condition was “the result of many years of neglect”.

Bus stop beside an orange hoarding reading "Be Ready" and "Blackwall Reach", with a concrete block of flats behind.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016

The first new homes were Phase 1A, at the north-west corner of the site: 98 homes, finished in March 2015. The council described them as “primarily for decanting tenants and resident home owners” from the estate.

Swan Housing, the developer, later said 79 were let to social housing residents and eight to other people living and working in Tower Hamlets. The rest went to leaseholders from Robin Hood Gardens. By July 2016, eleven resident owners had opted to move to a new Swan home.

At least one family had moved elsewhere in the borough by August 2016. The Ali family had lived on the estate for more than twenty years. They were in Mile End, in the first house they were offered, according to the writer Delwar Hussain.

By February 2016 everyone in the west block had been moved out, according to Thoburn. No published source says where each household went.

As flats emptied, the council let them to homeless households as temporary accommodation. Across the regeneration area, including homes bought from owners, it counted 53 such homes in 2014–15, 73 in 2015–16 and 80 in 2016–17.

The rents were set above social rent. By July 2016 they had brought the council’s housing account about £1.37m, and the council expected to need the east block empty during 2019.

Cabinet report, July 2016: a table of empty homes used as temporary accommodation, 53 in 2014/15, 73 in 2015/16 and 80 from 2016/17, with the rental income.
Blackwall Reach Regeneration Project: Update Budget Report, London Borough of Tower Hamlets, p. 826 July 2016London Borough of Tower Hamlets, democracy.towerhamlets.gov.ukWhat this provesThat the homes emptied by the decant and by buying out owners were relet to homeless households on temporary tenancies, and what that earned. The table counts homes across the regeneration area, not only the two blocks.
Looking up at a wall of glass blocks lighting a white landing, black mould along the ceiling edge.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Stair landing, west block · April 2016
Blue door marked "Fire exit keep clear" open onto a narrow empty deck, a blue door at its far end.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Access deck, west block · April 2016
Empty room with peeling blue and grey wallpaper, a radiator propped against the wall.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Empty flat, west block · April 2016
Narrow blue room with radiators on the floor and leaning on the wall, office towers in the window.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Empty flat, west block · April 2016
Empty room with a floral papered wall, a ceiling light and a radiator on the floor beside a wall of windows.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Empty flat, west block · April 2016
Wall of windows, frosted below, looking over bare trees to brick flats and office towers.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Empty flat, west block · April 2016
Through two windows of a dark, graffitied room, the long east block across the garden, washing on its balconies.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · Window in the west block · April 2016

On 7 September 2017 Swan told the Architects’ Journal that 27 council tenants and six home owners were still living in the east block. They would not be moved before 2020, and some would be rehoused in the new homes on the site.

In January 2023 the council’s risk register recorded that every leasehold had been bought. Secure and non-secure tenants were “still to rehouse”, and notices seeking possession had been served.

In May 2023 a caretaker told The Sun that ten flats were still officially occupied, with “a lot more squatters”. The council said it had not yet been able to move the remaining households because of “a severe shortage of available homes in our borough”.

Interpretation, James Wakefield:

In 2016 Peter Luck and I wrote that the estate “was condemned by those who had never lived there and much liked by those who had”. That came from talking to visitors at an exhibition. The 2007 consultation and the two speakers in 2012 show residents divided, and the 81% for demolition came with conditions about staying.

These photographs show the outside of a block where people lived, and rooms after the people had gone. They cannot show how anyone lived there, whether the estate should have been repaired, or where its tenants went. The records show repair estimates of £20m and more, and a council that chose to rebuild.

Demolition and after, 2017–26

Demolition of the west block began in December 2017. By May 2018 it had gone, and the east block, still lived in, could be seen from Cotton Street.

In 2017, before demolition began, the Victoria and Albert Museum acquired a three-storey section of the west block: both façades and the fittings of two flats. A 9m-high piece of it was shown at the 2018 Venice Architecture Biennale as Robin Hood Gardens: A Ruin in Reverse. In May 2025 it went on show at V&A East Storehouse, with recordings of former residents.

The east block stood for more than six years after the west block came down. Structural demolition began in December 2024.

Thoburn photographed the last section coming down on 12 March 2025. Sanctuary said on 7 May 2025 that demolition was still under way.

In 2017 the Mayor of London’s loan papers expected all five phases of Blackwall Reach to be finished by 2024–25. In May 2025 Sanctuary, which took over Swan in 2023, said more than 600 homes had been created, 214 of them allocated for social rent. A further 446 homes were approved in September 2025, and the programme now runs to 2031.

Dry lawn and trees below a long concrete block with many boarded windows, Canary Wharf towers behind.
Robin Hood Gardens, Poplar · September 2016

The ending was intended. Tower Hamlets decided on demolition in March 2008 and kept to it for seventeen years.

In 2012 a resident objector and the tenants’ chair both described twenty years of neglect. The wait was longer than the council’s own forecast: in 2016 it expected the east block to be empty during 2019, and tenants were still there in 2023.

Will the argument as to whether the right decisions were made continue? Almost certainly; and the final judgement cannot be predicted. Perspectives change.

Peter Luck and James WakefieldHistory panels, Robin Hood Gardens: Out of Time, Transition Photographers, September 2016
Evidencewhat remains unknown

Chronology

  • 1963: The London County Council commissions the Smithsons for Manisty Street, Poplar.
  • 1966: A new brief from the Greater London Council, which replaced the LCC in 1965, for the enlarged site.
  • 1968: Building begins.
  • 1972: The estate is completed: 214 flats.
  • 1974: Alison Smithson, “The Violent Consumer”.
  • 2006: A condition survey finds defects (reported).
  • 2007, August to November: English Partnerships consultation; 81% of those with a preference choose demolition. November: the Twentieth Century Society proposes listing.
  • 2008, 5 March: cabinet agrees demolition and decant status from September 2008. July: Margaret Hodge refuses listing.
  • 2009, 13 May: five-year certificate of immunity from listing.
  • 2012, 15 March: outline permission resolved for up to 1,575 homes; 30 March: permission secured (GLA).
  • 2014, January: my first visit. Emptied homes begin to be let as temporary accommodation (53 in 2014–15).
  • 2015, March: Phase 1A, 98 homes, completed. August: Historic England again declines to recommend listing; the minister is minded to issue a second certificate of immunity.
  • 2016, by February: the west block emptied. April and September: my visits. 16–18 September: Out of Time.
  • 2017, 7 September: 27 council tenants and six owners remain in the east block. November: the V&A announces its acquisition. December: west block demolition begins.
  • 2018, by May: west block demolished. Venice Architecture Biennale, A Ruin in Reverse.
  • 2023, January: secure and non-secure tenants still to be rehoused from the east block. 8 February: Swan becomes part of Sanctuary. May: ten flats still officially occupied.
  • 2024, December: structural demolition of the east block begins.
  • 2025, 12 March: Thoburn photographs the last section coming down; on 7 May Sanctuary still describes demolition as under way. May: the V&A fragment goes on show at V&A East Storehouse. September: 446 more homes approved.

What remains unknown

  • How many of the estate’s households moved into the new Blackwall Reach homes, and how many went elsewhere. No complete account of departure dates and destinations has been found, including for temporary tenants. Phase 1A’s lettings figures do not say how many came from Robin Hood Gardens.
  • When the last secure tenant left the east block. The record shows tenants still there in May 2023 and demolition starting in December 2024.
  • Whether three counts are the same exercise: the 130 of 140 households that Municipal Dreams says Darren Pauling found opposed demolition, the resident survey Building Design reported in June 2009, and the petition Pauling described in 2012 (120 of 130).
  • The survey behind the £20m repair estimate, and the “£70,000 per flat” figure often quoted with it, which I have not found in a council document.

Nick Thoburn photographed the last section of the east block coming down on 12 March 2025. The mound between the two blocks was kept: “The mound is retained”, say the landscape architects for Blackwall Reach.

BibliographyEvery source this page quotes or shows