Home

Balfron Tower

Poplar, London / 2014–15

Balfron Tower, 146 homes in Poplar, was built by the state and neglected by the state. It was sold, on HARCA's account, so that the building could be saved, though not its social housing.

In 2014 its landlord, Poplar HARCA, valued the tower as social housing at minus £4.03m. Kept as social rented homes, it would cost more to run and repair than it earned. That is a valuation, not a repair bill.

The last tenants had been moved out by March 2015; HARCA says 95% stayed in Tower Hamlets. The refurbished flats went on sale in 2019, and Novara Media reported in 2023 that none of the 139 relaunched in 2022 had sold. Since January 2024, 140 flats have been managed for private rent.

Most of these photographs, of the tower, its lobbies, lifts, walkways and fittings, were made in 2014, whilst the tower was being emptied. Five were made in vacated flats in June 2015, and two elsewhere at the tower that day. The records further down show what happened.

Concrete tower block and slender service tower joined by bridges, seen between green trees under blue sky.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · April 2014
Architect
Ernő Goldfinger, for the London County Council
Built
1965–67; first tenants February 1968
Homes
146 (136 flats, 10 maisonettes); 26 storeys
Listing
Grade II, 14 March 1996; Grade II*, 15 October 2015
Status
Private rented flats, managed by Way of Life since January 2024
Visits
April–September 2014; June 2015

Balfron Tower was saved as a building and lost as social housing.

The encounter

Interpretation, James Wakefield:

I first saw Balfron Tower as I drove out of the Blackwall Tunnel, and began photographing inside it in April 2014. An email to my Goldsmiths account invited people to take part in Balfron Season; at the time, I knew little about the wider issues.

In September 2014 I showed black-and-white photographs of the shared spaces in one of the flats, alongside three other photographers.

Two silhouetted figures walk along a concrete walkway towards the sun between high walls.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · April 2014

Balfron Season ran from mid-September to mid-October 2014. Bow Arts organised it, with support from Poplar HARCA, the tower’s landlord. HARCA helped facilitate the photographers’ show.

Hall with tall narrow windows, round lamps, a red pipe and sunlight across a tiled floor towards a dark red glazed door.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Entrance hall · April 2014

My photography exhibition was a visceral, aesthetic and largely superficial reaction to a building I actually knew very little about…

James WakefieldBalfron Tower, MA dissertation, Goldsmiths, University of London, p. 4, September 2015
Glazed wooden door in a concrete surround, with green marble walls, a red pipe and round lamps.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Entrance hall · April 2014
Moustache-printed coir doormat on red quarry tiles before a white door, flanked by blue wall tiles.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · August 2014
Concrete wall lettered 'BALFRON TOWER' in raised white letters, a blue-framed vent, narrow windows and a 'TOW AWAY ZONE' sign behind a shrub.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · June 2015
Red door with ring knocker beside a white tiled wall with two black and white portrait photographs.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Corridor · June 2015

The promise, 1963–68

Ernő Goldfinger designed the tower for the London County Council (LCC). At an LCC meeting on 1 February 1963 a planner said the proposed 27-storey block was “possibly out of scale with its surroundings”.

The minute was then amended, over his name, to “certainly out of scale”. The council went ahead.

Steep view down a concrete tower face to a busy road, trees, low blocks of flats and a distant gasholder frame.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · September 2014
Upward view of concrete tower walls and a glazed bridge between them against a blue sky.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · April 2014

The tower was built in 1965–67 with cast-on-site concrete cross-walls, not the prefabricated panels of system-built blocks. Its list entry says the concrete is “executed to a high standard”. A separate service tower holds the lifts and is linked to the 146 homes by bridges every third floor.

Vertical strips of speckled pale concrete and board-marked and rough grey concrete.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · August 2014
Dark wooden door frame, strips of concrete and glossy blue wall tiles side by side.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · August 2014
Concrete corridor with large wired-glass windows overlooking a skyline, red tiled floor and ceiling lights.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Corridor · September 2014
Two lifts on a yellow wall, round lights, a red pipe and sunlight across a worn tiled floor.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Lift lobby · September 2014

The nine access corridors form so many East End pavements, on which the normal life of the neighbourhood continues.

Ernő GoldfingerPress report on Rowlett Street, phase I, RIBA Goldfinger archive, as transcribed by David Roberts (balfrontower.org), 13 May 1968
Very dark lift interior with perforated metal panels, a handrail and a lit ceiling panel, facing a door with a small bright slit.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Lift · April 2014
Metal-panelled lift with open doors onto a sunlit landing with narrow windows and a round light.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Lift · April 2014

The first tenants moved in from February 1968. Goldfinger reported that the scheme’s first phase, the tower and its neighbouring old people’s flats, housed 160 families, all but two of them from Tower Hamlets.

Goldfinger and his wife Ursula lived in flat 130 for two months. He wrote that “the success of any scheme depends on the human factor”.

Empty room with patterned grey wallpaper on one wall, bare worn floor and white windows on the right.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Flat 130, bedroom · June 2015
Wired-glass window in a dark recess looking steeply down on the tower's shadow across a road, trees and housing.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · April 2014
Narrow wired-glass window in a dark wall showing blue sky, a distant concrete tower and a bridge between blocks.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · April 2014

I live on the 25th floor, but you couldn’t drag my wife and me out of the place now even though we lived on the ground floor before.

John MacDonald, tenantDavid Winder, “Architect sounds out his tenants”, The Christian Science Monitor, as transcribed by David Roberts (balfrontower.org), 17 June 1968

The same report recorded complaints almost every day of the Goldfingers’ stay. Two lifts were not enough for so large a building, there were no electric doorbells, and air vents let in draughts. Another tenant, Harry Smith, spoke of “very bad workmanship”.

On 16 May 1968 a gas explosion brought down one corner of Ronan Point, a system-built tower in Newham, and four people died. Bow Arts later wrote that the position of high-rise blocks in the public imagination was “essentially over-determined” by the disaster.

The neglect, 1969–2007

On 24 January 1969 the Guardian reported towers “already stained with rust” and added: “Here, too, vandalism is setting in.” In 1978 the East London Advertiser reported the Conservative housing boss George Tremlett naming Balfron as “an example of the worst in high rise design”. The same report found the top-floor corridors “neat and tidy, but eerily empty”.

The tower was listed Grade II in March 1996, which protected the design. The 2006 offer to tenants said the listed status made the cost of the work “significantly higher” than for typical council homes. It promised, if the transfer went ahead, that “all outstanding repairs would be undertaken”.

Hackney Citizen wrote in 2015 that Balfron “had suffered from an historic lack of maintenance”. Photographs made in 2014 cannot show how the tower was kept in earlier decades.

Slatted opening with bright light between the slats in a stained concrete wall, a black handrail running diagonally across and a plywood panel below.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Stairwell · August 2014
Round light with a ribbed concentric glass cover, lit yellow, on a grey stained surface.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · August 2014
Metal push button plate reading PUSH TO EXIT on a lime green panel in a wooden door.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · August 2014

The transfer and the decant, 2007–15

In November 2006 tenants voted to transfer their estates to the housing association Poplar HARCA, and the transfer was completed in December 2007. Balfron’s tenants were offered a choice: stay whilst the tower was refurbished, or move to one of 130 proposed homes elsewhere on the Brownfield Estate. The tower stands on that estate, and the homes needed planning permission.

The flats they left would be sold to help fund the estate’s regeneration. In 2006 HARCA wrote that this “choices” option meant “no resident will lose their home involuntarily”.

Section 3.4.5 of the offer: 130 new homes on the Brownfield Estate, and the choice to stay during the works or move to one of them.
East India Estates Offer, London Borough of Tower Hamlets, p. 24August 2006Balfron Tower: a building archive (David Roberts, 2015), balfrontower.orgWhat this provesWhat tenants were offered before they voted: refurbishment in place, or a new home on the Brownfield Estate, at their choice, subject to planning permission.

HARCA later blamed two things for the loss of its planned cross-subsidy: the 2008 financial crisis, and a planning refusal for a linked set of developments. From 2008 Bow Arts let empty flats to artists.

In the autumn of 2010 HARCA told all residents they would have to leave for the works. Its letter to one tenant that year called a return “possible but not probable”.

[I] see my flat, my home, as a safe haven with memories of my brothers, and an inspirational, poetic view that has helped me through very difficult times … I have lived for the past few weeks with the worry of losing my home.

I can see my old flat from the balcony of my new one, and I am starting a new life.

Michael Newman, tenantThe first part from his letter to Poplar HARCA, November 2010; the second after the decant. Benjamin Mortimer, “How the Balfron Tower tenants were ‘decanted’ and lost their homes”, Hackney Citizen, March 2015

HARCA said in 2022 that 95% of former residents stayed in Tower Hamlets, and that 81% stayed as HARCA residents within a square mile of Balfron. It said four households went further afield, without saying where. The only former residents HARCA says decided to return to the tower are leaseholders.

In August 2012 the social housing regulator’s viability report on HARCA, based on HARCA’s business plan, said: “Balfron will become a leaseholder-only block.”

The regulator's paragraph on refurbishing Carradale House and Balfron Tower, ending 'Balfron will become a leaseholder-only block.'
Viability Report on Poplar HARCA, social housing regulator, p. 6August 2012Balfron Tower: a building archive (David Roberts, 2015), balfrontower.orgWhat this provesWhat the regulator recorded of HARCA's business plan in 2012: a leaseholder-only tower, refurbished by a joint-venture partner in return for a share of the sales.

In 2014 HARCA described “converting the Grade 2 listed Balfron Tower from a social rented block to all private sales”. In the same document it valued the tower at minus £4.03m on the basis that it remained social housing (a “red book” valuation on existing use value for social housing).

That is the tower’s value to a landlord keeping it as social rented homes. Rent earned, less the cost of running and repairing it, came out below zero on HARCA’s assumptions. It is a valuation, not a repair bill, and the document does not show the working.

HARCA's bullet point on converting Balfron Tower to all private sales, with a red book valuation of minus £4.03m.
Value for Money Self Assessment 2013/14, Poplar HARCA, p. 32014Balfron Tower: a building archive (David Roberts, 2015), balfrontower.orgWhat this provesThat by 2014 HARCA planned to sell every flat, and valued the tower as social housing at minus £4.03m. Not a repair estimate, and the working is not shown.

Critics called the artists’ lets and Balfron Season “artwashing”. In October 2014 the Municipal Dreams blog wrote that the resident artists, Balfron Season and National Trust tours were “at minimum, complicit”.

Rab Harling lived in the tower as a Bow Arts artist-tenant from February 2011 and photographed nearly 120 of his neighbours’ homes. He later titled his account “Balfron Tower: the artwash of an icon”.

In December 2014 HARCA formed a joint venture with developers, and in February 2015 it was announced that no social housing would remain. In February 2017 the tower was sold to that joint venture, which HARCA half-owns.

Interpretation, James Wakefield:

I think Poplar HARCA was handed a poisoned chalice, and handled it badly. On its own valuation the tower was worth minus £4.03m as social housing.

The regulator’s 2012 report on HARCA’s plan put the repair at £90,000 to £100,000 a flat, and £20m for Balfron if no joint-venture partner was found. The refurbishment for private sale had an original budget of £40m and a reported cost of £57m.

Repairing the tower as social housing would have been a different job. I understand why a landlord with homes across Poplar would not spend that on one tower. What I hold against HARCA is the handling.

The regulator recorded a “leaseholder-only” plan in 2012, whilst tenants were told for two more years that a return was possible. I can find no published comparison of the alternatives.

The tower’s loss of social housing is not in dispute; the net change across the estate is. HARCA wrote in 2017 that 110 social homes were lost with Balfron, and that it would deliver 148 affordable homes, 126 for social rent, across the wider Brownfield Estate.

David Roberts, cross-referencing eleven documents from 2006–14, calculated a likely net loss of 42 to 83 social-rent homes on the estate’s footprint. HARCA disputes his figures, and its own count covers the wider Brownfield Estate regeneration.

What happened next, 2019–26

The flats, refurbished by Londonewcastle, Telford Homes and HARCA, went on sale on 27 September 2019, one-bedroom flats from £365,000. The sale was withdrawn in early 2020. 139 homes were relaunched on 23 July 2022 and withdrawn in spring 2023; Novara Media reported that none had sold.

Asked by Novara in 2023 why the flats had not sold, the partnership would not say, and spoke only of “the unpredictable current economic climate”. Novara reported on 4 August 2023, from an unnamed industry source, that agreed sales fell through because buyers were refused mortgages on the tower’s “non-standard” concrete frame. It called this “not a full explanation”.

HARCA said in 2022 that seven leaseholders had decided to return. By December 2023, The Developer reportedly recorded, a small number had moved back. On 9 January 2024 Way of Life was appointed to manage 140 flats for private rent.

Three kinds of ending meet here. Selling the tower was intended: HARCA’s business plan assumed it from 2012.

The repair backlog was acknowledged: in 2006 the offer to tenants promised that “all outstanding repairs would be undertaken”. That none of the flats sold, as Novara reported, was not what the 2012 plan assumed.

What I got right in 2015, and what I got wrong

Interpretation, James Wakefield:

In 2015 I made a fictional sales brochure that left out Balfron’s social housing history and the rehousing of its tenants by March 2015. The 2019 brochure also omits “social housing” and promises “a place of strong community”; I was right about the omission.

Balcony with a planter ledge of dried plants framing a skyline of glass towers and cranes under a cloudy sky.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Flat 130, balcony · June 2015
Welcome spread of the fictional Modern Estates brochure: 'Welcome to Balfron Tower' beside a photograph of the tower.
Modern Estates sales brochure (fiction), James Wakefield, pp. 4–52015Final visual project, MA Photography and Urban Cultures, GoldsmithsWhat this provesWhat the 2015 prediction expected the sales material to leave out.

Text from the 2019 Balfron Tower sales brochure: 'Balfron Tower will be a place of strong community, unified by design, space and art.'
Balfron Tower: A New Generation, sales brochure2019Londonewcastle with Poplar HARCA and Telford HomesWhat this provesHow the refurbished flats were described to buyers. It cannot show who bought them; Novara reported that none did.
Interpretation, James Wakefield:

I was wrong about the ending. In 2015 I expected a “capitalist monument” of luxury flats; Novara later reported that none had sold, and the flats are rented through a corporate operator.

I was wrong about HARCA too. In 2015 I read it as an agent of capital; the regulator’s 2012 report and HARCA’s own negative valuation changed my mind.

And the photographs misled me. The emptied flats I photographed in June 2015 read as eviction. The record shows a choice offered in 2006 and assurances that shifted; the photographs cannot show why anyone left.

Balcony with peeling paint framing houses, trees and glass towers beneath a cloudy sky.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Balcony of a vacated flat · June 2015
Kitchen with pine cabinets, bare walls, loose cables and debris across a dark floor.
A vacated flat, Balfron TowerJune 2015Photographs, James WakefieldWhat this provesWhat one flat contained after its occupants left. Not who lived there, when they left, or why.

Built by the state, neglected by the state and at one time representative of its failure, it has been forced to capitulate to private capital, in order to safeguard its future physical integrity, but to the detriment of its socialist foundations.

James WakefieldBalfron Tower, MA dissertation, Goldsmiths, University of London, conclusion, p. 43, September 2015
Room with white walls, brown floor, a blue checked mattress and a bright window with a wall heater.
Balfron Tower, Poplar · Flat 130, bedroom · June 2015
Interpretation, James Wakefield:

My own part needs saying. I showed my work in the tower with HARCA’s help, and in 2015 I asked whether I had been “complicit in the process of aiding the transition of the building from public asset to private real-estate”.

Owen Hatherley wrote in 2019 that critics and enthusiasts like him “probably helped it along, by turning brutalism into a coffee-table fetish object”. I was one of them.

Evidencewhat remains unknown

Chronology

  • 1963, 1 February: LCC planner calls the block “certainly out of scale”; the scheme goes ahead.
  • 1965–67: Built for the LCC, then the GLC.
  • 1968, February: first tenants move in; the Goldfingers live in flat 130 for two months. 16 May: Ronan Point partly collapses.
  • 1969, 24 January: the Guardian reports rust and vandalism.
  • 1978, 21 July: East London Advertiser reports George Tremlett calling Balfron “an example of the worst in high rise design”.
  • 1996, 14 March: listed Grade II.
  • 2006, August: offer document. November: tenants vote for transfer.
  • 2007, December: transfer to Poplar HARCA completed.
  • 2008: Bow Arts live/work lets begin.
  • 2010, autumn: all residents told they must leave. Return “possible but not probable”.
  • 2012, August: the regulator’s viability report on HARCA (“leaseholder-only block”).
  • 2014: value-for-money self-assessment, negative valuation of £4.03m. 10–21 September: Balfron Season photography show. 25 September: development LLP incorporated. December: joint venture formed.
  • 2015, February: no social housing announced. March: Hackney Citizen reports all tenants re-housed. 15 October: Grade II*. 16 December: planning permission and listed building consent granted.
  • 2017, February: tower sold to the joint venture.
  • 2019, 27 September: flats launched for sale.
  • 2020, early: sale withdrawn.
  • 2022, 23 July: 139 homes relaunched.
  • 2023, spring: all withdrawn; Novara later reported none sold. October: Telford Homes reports a £193m loss for 2022, partly on “the refurbishment of a listed residential tower”, understood to be Balfron. December: a small number of returning leaseholders have moved back.
  • 2024, 9 January: Way of Life appointed to manage 140 rented flats.

What remains unknown

  • Why, as Novara reported, none of the flats sold. The partnership would not say when Novara asked in 2023; the mortgage account rests on one unnamed source.
  • Whether HARCA ever compared keeping the tower as social housing with selling it. I have not found a published options appraisal for Balfron; HARCA’s 2013/14 statement refers to “extensive stock option appraisals” only in general.
  • The net change in social-rent homes on the estate. HARCA counts across the wider Brownfield Estate regeneration; Roberts counted the estate’s footprint.
  • How many households HARCA’s figures on former residents (95% in Tower Hamlets, 81% still HARCA residents) cover. I have not found the number of households those percentages cover.
  • Whether HARCA met the 2007 transfer agreement’s duty to use “all reasonable endeavours” to build 130 dwellings, or an equal number of habitable rooms, for Balfron and Carradale residents.
  • When the last social tenant left the tower. By March 2015 all tenants had been rehoused; HARCA says 95% of former residents stayed in Tower Hamlets.
  • Why HARCA counted 140 rented flats in 2024, when 146 were refurbished, 139 marketed and seven leaseholders returned. The Evening Standard put returning leaseholders at six in 2019, and 146 minus six is 140; no source links the figures.

Balfron Tower still stands beside the northern approach to the Blackwall Tunnel. In 1963 the LCC expected it to give “a high sense of visual drama” to anyone emerging from the tunnel.

BibliographyEvery source this page quotes or shows